COVID-19: The Recovery will Happen in Public Space

Does Your City Have What It Takes? A Guide to Auditing Innovation Districts

Feb 23, 2018
Mar 2, 2018

This article is part of the Bass Initiative on Innovation and Placemaking, a collaboration between PPS and the Brookings Institution.

Nowadays, it seems that innovation districts are cropping up left and right. Urban and suburban leaders alike are attracted to these hubs, where people, resources, and institutions like universities cluster together. Innovation districts bear the promise of an economic boost, new jobs, and new solutions to old problems. But are they living up to their name?

All too often, a focus on attracting tech companies and the millennial workforce distracts from the real potential of these districts, which lies in making better use of a city's existing assets, including current residents and businesses. As a result, many innovation districts become isolated physical and economic enclaves that fail to create a more inclusive economy or a public realm that connects, inspires, and incubates new ideas.

So if it is an innovation district that everyone is after, what does it take to create one that really works for everyone? Through the the Bass Initiative on Innovation and Placemaking, PPS and the Brookings Institution partnered up to answer this question. This week, PPS and Brookings released a new guide to support local leaders in assessing the assets that comprise their local innovation ecosystems. Drawing on our experience applying this framework in cities like Pittsburgh, Oklahoma City, and Philadelphia, the new guide provides aspiring urban leaders with a step-by-step approach to assessing a city’s innovation landscape, starting with five key questions:

  1. Critical mass: Where are your region’s highest concentrations of “innovation assets”?
  2. Innovation capacity: Is the district leveraging and aligning its distinctive advantages to grow and strengthen its firms innovation capacity?
  3. Diversity and inclusion: Does the district have an inclusive, diverse, and opportunity-rich environment?
  4. Quality of place: Does the district have physical and social assets that attract a diversity of firms and people, increase interactions, and accelerate innovative outcomes?
  5. Leadership: Does the district have the leadership necessary to succeed?

The in-depth guide provides a framework for both qualitative and quantitative evaluations of an "innovation ecosystem,” mapping the assets that a place already has, and examining its capacity to grow. This exercise in auditing the strengths and weaknesses of a place covers all the ingredients of a successful innovation district; from inclusive hiring policies to a healthy start-up culture. It provides a first step on the road to an innovation district worthy of the name.

Innovation—in the broadest sense—is trending for a reason. It can be what sets a place apart both economically and socially. A truly effective innovation district can be the difference between isolated industries, job markets, and research, and a more connected, inclusive, place-led economy. The first step to creating a great innovation district, and even a great place, is to take stock of what it has to offer in the first place.

Download the full Innovation District Audit Guide

Related Articles & Resources
COVID-19: The Recovery will Happen in Public Space