Federation Square, in Melbourne, was a $500 Million design projcet whose primary goal was to create a great place.

Federation Square, in Melbourne, had the primary goal to create a great place.

The Role of Placemaking in Fostering Better and More Creative Design

“Architecture needs to evolve from expressing the individual’s creativity to supporting the community’s creativity.” — Silvia Soonets, Architect, Arqui5

If the primary goal of architects and landscape architects was to create places that people want to be in, would we be designing our communities the way we do today? If contemporary architecture was asked to be responsive to community outcomes, public uses and human comfort would it be done differently? Would it create more demand for the skills of designers?

Looking at design magazines and looking at our cities, it appears that the professional shaping of the built environment has been reduced to creating isolated physical forms with little consideration for their contribution to a larger experience of a place. This reality no doubt closely reflects a demand on design professionals to merely create designs (for buildings, parks, roads, master plans, etc.). Since they have rarely been asked to create places that attract people, it follows that they have not, for the most part, created such places.

At a time when the skills, technology and need for creating successful places has never been greater, there are so few truly successful examples of new public spaces being created or improved.

It Will Take Architects to Create Great Places

Design professions can be much better employed in shaping the public realm. The role of design can and should be much broader and bolder, but will undermine itself if it continues to try to drive a city building or Placemaking process the same way it does today. If the role of design is to create places, design actually become more valuable and creative while developing more productive relationships with clients, partners and communities it is serving.

But if we merely focus on the goals of “good” or “world class” design as an end in itself, we limit the potential of what can be accomplished, and we ignore architecture’s ability to respond creatively to context. When a project prioritizes creating places that meet the needs of its community, the design problems and solutions become more clear, interest in the project rises, and talented people step up to collaborate in the process.

How PPS is Working to Support the Design Professions

Our intention at Project for Public Spaces is to boost the prospects of success for urban designers, architects and landscape architects by creating public demand for quality urban spaces and educating communities to work creatively and constructively with design professionals. Ultimately, we want designers’ work to be more valued than it is today.

PPS works to understand, bring about, celebrate, and inspire public spaces that are valuable to cities with the hope that we can get more of them. When public spaces are not adequately used, do not add value to a community and or become “owned” by the citizens that are meant to use them, it is not only a loss for the community, but a blow to the design professions whose contributions have been limited.

By focusing on the broader goal of creating places, we are consistently able to draw more creativity out of the various professions, as well as the communities they serve. We believe that creating successful places should be easier and more rewarding than it is today, and we dedicate ourselves to making that happen.

Keep your finger on the pulse–sign up for Placemaking News today! subscribe

  • jct

    This is just becoming ridiculous. I’m sorry to see PPS continuing the division between architects and planners, designers and community that has become so prevalent in theory and practice. Provoking people who want to do the right thing is not productive. In fact, in my experience, more architects take community planning classes than planners take design studios.
    Perhaps everyone in this current “smackdown” meant to address their negativity toward developers- you know, those people who are the largest campaign contributors in our country and decide the fate of most of our public places these days. It’s all fine to say that architects should rise up and unite, but I’m seeing planners and community boards approve plans that architects would have preferred not to have drawn in the first place if they had their way. Isn’t that what we call a double standard?

  • ekent

    jct, Thanks for your response. Indeed it is one we have heard repeatedly from frustrated architects, and one I think we understand.

    The division of disciplines that you describe is causing frustration and dysfunction for everyone, even for those that come at a project with a multi-disciplinary approach. The place approach we practice, and are suggesting in the article, is a way to reinvent these relationships and draw effectively on the skills and creativity of all involved.

    While certainly developers have done great damage as market managers for much of the public realm, blaming the client has not accomplished much. In fact it is this kind of blaming that really is perpetuating the divisions between disciplines. We are also starting to see many developers looking more holistically and progressively at Placemaking — really engaging architects, planners and communities with great results.

    Architects have seemed to be the most defensive and prickly about our message, where traffic engineers, planners, developers, community groups, etc. have openly taken the same criticism and looked for new ways to behave.

  • http://www.newyorkbygehry.com/ New York Architect

    Hi, 

    Federation Square is really so beautiful guys.

  • http://www.theuniuni.com/ Payton_vege

    Amazing write-up! This could aid plenty of people find out more about this particular issue. Are you keen to integrate video clips coupled with these? It would absolutely help out. Your conclusion was spot on and thanks to you; I probably won’t have to describe everything to my pals. I can simply direct them here!